As much as I have the right to make out, it"s generally assumed the Elves room taller than Men, ~ above average. Yet it doesn"t actually explicitly say this everywhere in the books. Is this simply a spillover native the Peter Jackson films, or does that actually have actually some truth to it? I in reality think the Elves are much shorter than Men, as it states in the kids of Húrin that Nellas showed up as a maiden that his own age. Whether the was because she want to show up so is debatable, however it also says later that Túrin flourished to be tall amongst Men, and taller than the Elves.I am discounting the info in the book of lost Tales regarding the height of the Elves, as this appears to it is in outdated, and go hand in hand through the old ide of Fading.


You are watching: How tall are elves in lord of the rings

There are numerous accounts by Tolkien of the Stature of Elves.He says that Elu Thingol to be something favor 7"4" tall (The Tallest of all Elves). And also that on mean the Elves were taller in stature than were men.Remember this is one AVERAGE, meaning if you take a arbitrarily Elf, and a arbitrarily Human, the radom Elf will certainly be taller than the random person for practically all instance.This walk not typical that there space not details Humans that room taller than the average Elf, such as Túrin.Let"s take a couple of analogies to show this. Say that we have two groups, group E and Group M. And also that each team has ten members. Let"s say that the heights the the members of these teams CAN BE anywhere from 1 to 10 (These space not actual measurements, just arbitrary categories, where 1 = Shortest, and 10 = tallest).So, to give an instance of the members of each Group:Group E (Member"s Heights): 6, 7, 8, 7, 7, 8, 6, 5, 9, 10Group M (Member"s Heights): 7, 4, 5, 6, 5, 6, 6, 6, 8, 7The Average height of group E is 7.3, when the Average elevation of team M is 6.Overall, team M is "Smaller in Stature" than team E, also though there is one member of team M (with a height of "8") the is taller than the median member of team E. And in group E we view that one member (with a height of "10") is the Tallest of every members of either population.You can also have such populaces where team E can be such the the Average elevation remained higher than that of team M, yet group M had the Tallest Member of one of two people population.And we also have the instances of both The Silmarillion and The history of Middle-earth whereby it is mentioned that Elves were normally taller than Men. There are some allusions to this in The mr of the Rings once Tolkien defines Glorfindel and also Elrond, and also when Sam is mistaken for an Elven Warrior in ~ the fortress ~ above Cirith Ungol.Plus.... Tolkien uses Norse and also Finnish Elves together the theme for the Elves that Middle-earth, and the Elves the Beowulf and the Saxons, whereby such Elves were really tall, otherworldly beings. They are a kind of Archetype because that a "Perfect Human," and for many of human being History, tall, pale, and also dark-haired v pale eye colors has been seen as an "ideal the perfection and beauty" to humans in Europe (and even much the Asia, conserve for having White Hair rather of Black).MB
*

Thanks for clarifying that. Girlfriend seem to know a lot much more a bout it than I do! are you certain that elves in Saxon and also Norse mythology to be tall, however? ns seem come recall them being little beings who resulted in sickness by shooting arrows in ~ animals. Elf-shot. I might well it is in wrong, though.
M
Matthew BaileyNew Member
mallos said:
Thanks because that clarifying that. You seem to understand a lot an ext a bout it 보다 I do! room you certain that elves in Saxon and Norse mythology were tall, however? ns seem to recall lock being small beings who resulted in sickness by shoot arrows at animals. Elf-shot. I may well it is in wrong, though.


See more: (A) What Do The Coefficients In A Balanced Equation Represent ?

I to be pretty certain of this. The vikings Elves in specific are a template for Tolkien"s elves, as they are said to live v the Vanir (Maia - the Nordic god were split into 2 types, choose those of Middle-earth. In the Nordic, this was the Aesir and also the Vanir) in Aelfheim through Freyr.I cannot uncover an online resource that consists of much about the Anglo-Saxon"s Elves, yet prior to the settlement of the saxon guy in England, they were simply a phibìc European Norse/Germanic people, who had especially the exact same Myths together did the norse (as walk the Goths, that are simply Saxons that went West and South, fairly than North and West).But it is the Anglo-Saxon explicate of Elves where we check out the Elves "Diminishing." The Saxon Elves (Alb, Aelf, Alß, etc. - relying on Saxon origin: North, South, West, East). After ~ the Saxons worked out in England, their Christianization led to the ban of the praise of the Aelfir. This led them to diminish in stature, together the Christian Church sought come marginalize them native the Heroic, Idealized form, to a lesser, demonic reality (During the Dark/Middle ages the Christian Church sought to affix Nature and the Pagan divine beings with Satan, and also the Elves were no exception). Therefore thus went from gift tall, fierce warriors (who additionally had a propensity to love singing, the woods, the stars, were beautiful past compare, etc.) that could come to be invisible to gift small, elusive and dainty beings that were capricious and also cruel.It was this adjust that ongoing through Elizabethan England to victorian (during the revival of "Fairy" in England in ~ the time) that Tolkien fought against and rejected.MB