by Colton Massey, Victor Chan" rel="author">Colton Massey, Victor Chan · published August 23, 2017 · update September 13, 2020


Prior to setting foot in Hogwarts, harry perception that Slytherin was tainted through his interactions through Hagrid, Draco, and also Ron. These interactions do Harry predisposed come dislike Slytherin. However, think about an alternative timeline whereby Harry had been Sorted right into Slytherin. How dramatically would this have changed the series?

*

It’s crucial to keep in mind that bother is an innately empathetic person. We an initial learn this at the zoo in Sorcerer’s Stone. Bother concludes the being grounding in a glass tank “was worse than having actually a cupboard together a bedroom” (SS 2). In Chamber that Secrets, Harry speak Dobby that his plight together a house-elf “makes the Dursleys sound almost human” (CS 2). In Deathly Hallows, Griphook notes the Harry’s empathy towards others makes him “an inexplicable wizard” (DH 24). This personality trait would have adjusted readers’ perspectives toward Slytherin by presenting them with a likable personality from the House. The juxtaposition between Harry’s personality and the stereotypes the students native the other homes held about Slytherin would have enriched the series.

You are watching: What if harry was sorted into slytherin

*

Harry would have actually been internally conflicted if he had actually been Sorted into Slytherin. Although he still would have actually felt that hogwarts was the only ar he had ever belonged, he could have felt wary forming relationships with the kids of fatality Eaters. However, this might have offered credence come Dumbledore’s notion (spoken by Hagrid, GoF 24) the “people can turn the end OK even if their family members weren’… fine … all tha’ respectable.” In Half-Blood Prince, showing on Dumbledore’s death, harry thinks around “the fear in Malfoy’s voice” and also concludes that “he despised Malfoy still for his infatuation v the Dark Arts, but now the tiniest fall of pity mingled v his dislike.” If bother had communicated with Draco and also other Slytherins on a daily basis, he can have sympathized with them earlier. The Slytherins would have been illustrated as assets of their environments.

*

Snape’s potential reaction to Harry being Sorted right into Slytherin is more ambiguous and complicated to consider. Return Snape might not have actually projected his memory of James ~ above Harry, that still would have actually been predisposed to dislike him by virtue of him being James potter’s son. Harry being in Slytherin would not have changed this fact. Moreover, if take care of had been in Slytherin, the argument can be made that Snape would have seen less of Lily in him 보다 he currently did. The unlikely the Snape would have had actually a warm relationship through Harry since throughout the novels that isn’t shown to be an especially warm to many of the students. However, based upon the id that the favors students indigenous his own House, Snape might not have actually been as vindictive towards Slytherin Harry. It’s likely that Snape would have actually acted cold and also distant toward Harry but would not have reprimanded or mistreated that as lot as he does canonically.

*

It’s not past the kingdom of creative thinking to imply that if harry had remained in Slytherin, climate Dumbledore would have actually kept a closer watch on him. Being scarred by his previous experience v Tom Riddle, Dumbledore would have taken heightened precautions to avoid Harry indigenous traversing down a similar slope of moral disrepute. Plot-wise, having actually Harry it is in in Slytherin would have actually resulted in Dumbledore gift much more aware the his link to Voldemort. Dumbledore would have actually had strong evidence to support his Horcrux theory lot earlier and also so may have started hunting down and destroying those Horcruxes before Voldemort’s body was regenerated. This would have placed Dumbledore in a much much more advantageous position, and also so Voldemort may have actually been much more easily defeated.

See more: A Lawsuit Seeking Damages For &Quot;All Persons Similarly Situated&Quot; Is Called

*

Harry’s decision to challenge Voldemort i will not ~ have adjusted if that had been in Slytherin due to the fact that it wouldn’t have adjusted the truth that Voldemort killed his parents. However, the collection may have actually been more morally dilemmatic. We would have seen the second Wizarding war from the perspective of Slytherin House, i beg your pardon would have actually been strife v in-fighting as those that opposed and also those who sustained Voldemort clashed. The Slytherins that knew Harry well would have actually rallied behind him. Furthermore, if us assume that Slytherin Harry developed a friendship v Draco, then possibly this friendship would have offered Draco the strength to diverge indigenous the course that his parents want him to follow.

Don’t forget! Tickets come rewildtv.com Live! 2017: Nineteen Years later on are still accessible for purchase, and we would certainly LOVE to satisfy you in Orlando for an amazing Potter fandom experience! Check the end our website for details and then obtain your ticket to have actually a private, miracle evening v rewildtv.com and the amazing talent native the Potter films!