Why does Shakespeare choose to have actually Benedick and also Beatrice profess their love because that one another at the end of action 4, scene 1 that Much Ado around Nothing? Why does Beatrice questioning Benedick to prove his love by killing Claudio?
Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are genuine professors, teachers, and also scholars who usage their scholastic expertise to tackle her toughest questions. Educators go v a rigorous applications process, and also every prize they send is reviewed by our in-house editorial team.

You are watching: Why does beatrice ask benedick to kill claudio


College Professor, expert Writer

B.A. Indigenous Kent State university M.A. Indigenous West Virginia State university Ph.D. Native Bowling eco-friendly State University

Educator because 2019

1,082 answers

very early in Shakespeare"s Much Ado around Nothing, the audience learns the there is some kind of romantic history between Beatrice and also Benedick.

at the beginning of the play, Leonato, the branch of Messina, receives a letter to the effect that Don Pedro has actually been victorious in battle, and...

Start your 48-hour totally free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Gain rewildtv.com ad-free and cancel anytime.

Very early in Shakespeare"s Much Ado around Nothing, the audience learns the there is some sort of romantic history between Beatrice and Benedick.

At the start of the play, Leonato, the governor of Messina, receives a letter to the impact that Don Pedro has actually been victorious in battle, and also is returning house to Messina. Seemingly out of the blue, Beatrice asks around Benedick, identify him obliquely and derogatorily:

BEATRICE. I pray you, is Signior Mountanto went back from the wars or no? (1.1.25-26)

Beatrice piles insults ~ above Benedick because that the next fifty lines, and when Benedick shows up in the scene, she continues to insult him to his face in a verbal exchange comparable to, yet considerably much shorter than the exchange between Petruchio and also Katherine in The Taming of the Shrew, which Shakespeare wrote two years prior to he wrote Much Ado around Nothing.

Clearly, Beatrice and Benedick are in love. Equally clear is that they have great challenge expressing your love to every other.

At the masked party in plot 2, scene 1, Beatrice and also Benedick are dancing together, and also both are masked, back Beatrice knows rather well she"s dancing v Benedick, who thinks the fooling Beatrice through his disguise. Beatrice once again take away the possibility to rail against Benedick:

BENEDICK. I pray you, what is he?

BEATRICE. Why, he is the prince"s jester, a an extremely dull fool. Only his gift is in devising impossible slanders. None butlibertines delight in him; and also the commendation is not in his wit, yet in his villainy; because that he both pleases men andangers them, and then castle laugh at him and beat him. Iam certain he is in the fleet. (2.1.118-123)

Later in that very same scene, Beatrice offers a clue to the reason for this unceasing animosity between Benedick and herself:

DON PEDRO. Come, lady, come; you have actually lost the heart of Signior Benedick.

BEATRICE. Indeed, my lord, he lent it me awhile, and I offered him use for it—a dual heart because that his solitary one. Marry, once before he won it that me v false dice; as such your Grace might well to speak I have actually lost it. (2.1.243-248)

Apparently, their confession of love to each various other in action 4, step 1 isn"t the first time the they"ve expressed together feelings, although your previous romantic experience appears not to have gone very well.

The scheming the Benedick"s girlfriend in action 2, step 3, and the scheming the Beatrice"s girlfriend in act 3, scene 1 to do Benedick and also Beatrice confront up to their true feelings because that each other, helps prepare castle for their declarations of love in act 4, step 1.

Act 4, step 1 begins with what is an alleged the be the marriage of Hero and also Claudio, yet the scene takes a sharp rotate in a various direction.

Claudio accuses Hero of gift unfaithful to him, Hero faints, Hero"s father is apoplectic, and also Claudio marches out of the church in self-righteous indignation, leaving Hero in what shows up to be a dead pass out at the foot the the altar.

For his part, Benedick appears confused around the entirety marriage business:

BENEDICK. This looks not like a nuptial. (4.1.67)

Fortunately, Hero recovers from she fainting spell. The Friar that was an alleged to have performed the ceremony imagine a plan whereby word will certainly be given out that Hero is dead, to give Hero"s friends time to find the truth of the matter. (What is it through Shakespeare"s friars who space forever devising plan that encompass the heroine that the play showing up to it is in dead?)

Beatrice is in utter distress at the unfortunate turn of events, and also she"s enraged in ~ Claudio for his unforgivable treatment of she cousin, Hero.

Benedick feels sorry for Beatrice, and tries to comfort her. Benedick provides to do every little thing it take away to do Beatrice feeling better, and after yet another insult come his face, declares his love because that her:

BEATRICE. Ah, just how much could the male deserve of me that would appropriate her!

BENEDICK. Is there any way to display such friendship?

BEATRICE. A an extremely even way, yet no together friend.

BENEDICK. Might a guy do it?

BEATRICE. The is a man"s office, however not yours.

BENEDICK. I perform love nothing in the world so well together you. (4.1.271-277)

Beatrice is momentarily captured off guard—as is the audience at this unexpected turn of events in the center of every one of this marital relationship drama—and declares she love for Benedick. She tries to take it back, yet eventually confirms she feelings because that him.

Benedick is caught up in the moment, and, passionate to prove his love, makes a fateful request:

BENEDICK. Come, bid me carry out anything because that thee. (4.1.297)

Beatrice"s an answer to Benedick"s heartfelt but naive inquiry is same fateful:

BEATRICE. Kill Claudio. (4.1.298)

Benedick is taken aback:

BENEDICK. Ha! no for the large world! (4.1.299)

This is not what Beatrice wants to hear. She rants and raves against Claudio, wishes she to be a guy so she can eat Claudio"s love in the market place, insults Benedick"s manhood, rejects his love, and also resolves to "die a woman with grieving" (4.1.330).

See more: I Believe In The Sun Lyrics, I Believe In The Sun By Carey Landry

Benedick offers in:

BENEDICK. Enough, i am engaged, ns will an obstacle him. I will kiss her hand, and so ns leave you. By this hand, Claudio candlestick render me a dear account. (4.1.336-338)

Beatrice doesn"t say anything additional in the scene, but she"s no doubt pleased the Benedick has actually chosen to prove his love for she by agreeing come avenge Claudio"s reprehensible actions towards Hero on Beatrice"s behalf.